Keywords
best interests
lethal defect
suffering
futile therapy
discontinuation of life support
withdrawal of treatment
How to Cite
Abstract
The article addresses the issue of health decisions for the youngest children with fatal congenital malformations whose treatment has no chances of success. It reviews Polish cases against the background of documented cases from the British and American area, generally of well-founded court decisions. According to author, the universally applied criterion of the child's welfare should be understood as the best interests of the child, understood as a balance of benefits, enjoyment of life, burdens, discomforts and suffering. On the basis of foreign judgments and with reference to current medical knowledge the author has formulated criteria according to which, in the opinion of the author's opinion, the cessation of treatment should be decided upon, including certain palliative measures: surgical corrections of palliative care: surgical revisions, artificial ventilation and nutrition and hydration. Even feeding may under certain circumstances may prove unhelpful or even harmful. The right to die in peace and dignity should be respected in this way, among others among other things, to spare unnecessary suffering, even when this tantamount to shortening an already ending life.
References
A Children’s Physician, Non-treatment of defective newborn babies, "The Lancet" , 2/1979
Annas G. J., J.D, MPH, The Case of Baby Jane Doe: Child Abuse or Unlawful Federal Intervention?, "American Journal of Public Health", July 1984, vol. 74, No 7,https://www.google.com/url?esrc=s&q=&rct=j&sa=U&url=https://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/pdf/10.2105/AJPH.74.7.727&ved=2ahUKEwii8c6pya2CAxUfBhAIHctUBUoQFnoECAkQAg&usg=AOvVaw0BObm_39_gfjYezWgkPyc
Bartkowska-Śniatkowska A, Byrska-Maciejasz E, Cettler M, et al. Guidelines regarding ineffective maintenance of organ functions (futile therapy) in paediatric intensive care units, "Anaesthesiol Intensive Ther" 2021; 53, 5
Biesaga T., Bioetyka utylitarystyczna Zbigniewa Szawarskiego, [w] Bioetyka polska, red. T. Biesaga, Wydawnictwo Naukowe PAT Kraków 2004
Campbell A.G.M., The Right to be allowed to die, "Journal of Medical Ethics" 1983, nr 1
Chambers M., Baby Doe: hard cases for parents and courts, "New York Times", Jan. 8, 1984, https://www.nytimes.com/1984/01/08/nyregion/baby-doe-hard-case-for-parents-and-courts.html
Chicago Doctors Separate Deformed Siamese Twins In Nine-Hour Operation, "The Washington Post" 17.VII.1982
Chrzęszczyk M., Rozszczep kręgosłupa – na czym polega spina bifida? Jak wyglądają leczenie i rehabilitacja osób z rozszczepem kręgosłupa?, 25.X.2020, https://www.doz.pl/czytelnia/a15505-Rozszczep_kregoslupa__na_czym_polega_spina_bifida_Jak_wygladaja_leczenie_i_rehabilitacja_osob_z_rozszczepem_kregoslupa
Drewa G., Ferenc T., Genetyka medyczna, Podręcznik dla studentów. Wydawnictwo URBAN & PARTNER, Wrocław 2011
Duff R.S., Campbell A.G.M., Moral and Ethical Dilemmas in the Special-care Nursery "New England Journal of Medicine" Oct. 25, 1973 nr 289
Duff , R.S. and Campbell A.G.M. , Moral and ethical dilemmas: Seven years into the debate about human
ambiguity, "Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science" 447/1980
Dyskusja: O racjonalne decyzje w opiece neonatalnej. Przypadek kliniczny: Madzia Słabiak, "Diametros" 15.IX. [PDF] Przypadek kliniczny: Madzia Słabiak - Hospicjum Perinatalne perinatalne.pl › pliki › Artykul › 1056_przypadek-kliniczny-madzia-s... https://www.google.com/url?esrc=s&q=&rct=j&sa=U&url=https://perinatalne.pl/pliki/Artykul/1056_przypadek-kliniczny-madzia-slabiak.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwid7rbtp7CCAxXiJBAIHQwTAkwQFnoECAoQAg&usg=AOvVaw2hDCAvkXBI7cqaKnufiJ6U
Gieruszczak-Białek D., Klinika Pediatrii Warszawski Uniwersytet Medyczny, Zespół Downa (trisomia 21. chromosomu): przyczyny, objawy i leczenie, portal "Medycyna Praktyczna", https://www.mp.pl/pacjent/pediatria/choroby/genetyka/152284,zespol-downa
Gunn M.J., Smith J.C., Arthur's case and the right to life of a Down syndrome child, "The Criminal Law Review" 1985
Horan D.J., Balch B.J., Infant Doe and Baby Jane Doe: Medical Treatment of the Handicapped Newborn, "The Linacre Quarterly", Vol. 52 No 1 February 1985
Huxtable R., Law, Ethics and Compromise at the Limits of Life, To treat or not to treat?, Routlege 2013
Kawalec W., Grenda R., Kulus M., Aberracje chromosomowe, Pediatria I, Wydawnictwo Lekarskie PZWL, Warszawa 2019
Kerr K., Reporting the Case of Baby Jane Doe, "The Hastings Center Report", Vol. 14, No. 4 (Aug., 1984); https://www.jstor.org/stable/3561158
Linacre Centre (The Linacre Centre for Health Care Ethics), Euthanasia and clinical practice: trends, principles and alternatives. A Working Party report (1982), [w] L. Gormally (ed.) Euthanasia, Clinical Practice and the Law , London 1994
Matuszczak E., Dębek W., Hermanowicz A., Oksiuta M., Dzienis-Koronkiewicz E,, Metody usprawniania i rehabilitacji dzieci urodzonych z przepukliną oponowo-rdzeniową, "Neurologia" Vol. 21/2012, nr 43
McCormick R. A., To Save or to Let Die. The Dilemma of Modern Medicine, "Journa1 of American Medical Association", July 8 1974, nr 229
Osman A., Ferriman A., Timmins N., Women cry “Thank God” as Dr Arthur is cleared, "The Times" z 6. XI.1981
Robertson J. A., DiIemma in Danville, "Hasting Center Report", 1981, vol. 11, nr 5
Rutkowska M., Noworodek skrajnie niedojrzały między życiem a śmiercią. Granice medycznej interwencji, "Etyka" nr 49, 2014
Szawarski Z., Moralne problemy dotyczące opieki nad dziećmi nieuleczalnie chorymi, "Studia Filozoficzne" nr 2 (220) 1984
Szewczyk K., Should parents have the right to make life-and-deadth decisions concerning critically ill infants? (in Polish), "Diametros" 34 (grudzień 2012), cz.V https://diametros.uj.edu.pl/diametros/article/view/504/1136
Śmigiel R. i in., Genetycznie uwarunkowane zaburzenia rozwoju u dzieci, Wydawnictwo Lekarskie PZWL, Warszawa 2021
Williams G., Letter: Life of a Child , "The Times" , 13.VIII.1981
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2023 Maria Boratyńska